Talk:List of misconceptions: Difference between revisions
From Mariopedia, a wiki on Mario, Yoshi, Wario, Donkey Kong, Super Smash Bros., and more!
Jump to navigationJump to search
no edit summary
mNo edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 6:
::::Not going to lie, I'm still in favor of [[Mario Portal]] as a source (but I won't insist certain things are, like Rocky Wrench thing for ''Mario Galaxy'') -- it is on an official website from Nintendo of Japan & mistakes do happen, like several in Prima guides, also officially licensed. And I've heard of ''Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour'' (I think that was it) that had two enemy names on the scoreboard. I'm also not happy about some articles like Moofish back to Mogyo (in response to the disagreement, I decided to port over my article to Nintendo Wiki with the [[mh:nintendo:Moofish|Moofish]] name intact). Some would see Mariopedia as the primary resource whereas Nintendo Wiki as the secondary). But this isn't my wiki & I'm outnumbered 2 to 1 on this, so. [[User:Bawitdaba|Bawitdaba]] ([[User talk:Bawitdaba|talk]]) 16:34, October 16, 2022 (UTC)
:::::The Japanese one is probably fine (like with the Super Mario Bros. Encyclopedia). It is just that English translation version that is unreliable and blatantly wrong in most aspects. It wasn’t just a couple of errors, there was just so much of them referring to enemies by the wrong names or calling them completely separate species (especially with the Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario Land 2 sections). That same section with Mogyo being called Moofish had plenty of inconstant names like either referring to enemies as generic English names or just using the Japanese names. And with the Super Mario Galaxy section in particular, it tends to treat separate species as the exact same as other separate species (such as the aforementioned Monty being called Rocky Wrench and also Puffer Fish being called a Spiny Cheep Cheep). You should really discuss this with HannaMontanaFan to since he helped with discovering that the Mario Portal is illegitimate. Also any questions about the previous paragraph I written? [[User:MontyMoleLoreMaster|MontyMoleLoreMaster]] ([[User talk:MontyMoleLoreMaster|talk]]) 17:04, October 16, 2022 (UTC)
::::::That is corruption at it's finest, it seems as though it's gotten worse since I left. I remember trying to challenge them on what they were doing, (such as the Trivia removals, the compacting of the sections, as well as some of the page merges) for my ban, it was because I actually fixed up an image template (or something I kind of forgot) but I didn't realize that another user was doing that as their project. This in turn scored me a 90-day ban, during the ban, I then moved to Wikia (or Fandom as they're calling it now (back then it was still Wikia)) and about halfway through, I decided not to return after the ban expired because my experiences on there were mostly bad. And like you said MMLM, it has gotten less creditable as like merging Boss Bass and Big Bertha with Mega Cheep Cheep and the other large Cheep Cheeps with Cheep-Chomp for instance despite the clear differences. It was just as bad on the MarioBoards as well because I remember it being rather toxic at points there too. [[User:HannahMontanaFan|HannahMontanaFan]] ([[User talk:HannahMontanaFan|talk]]) 21:58, October 16, 2022 (UTC)
| |||
